How it works
How a dossier is made
Our own research workflow, on current frontier AI models: a team of specialised agents, each with one job, and a separate check before anything is published.
§ 1
The workflow
Five stages, from the question to the check. The same workflow for every company.
A Moatsight dossier edition covers one company's latest report in a short brief and up to four parts: the business, the earnings, the valuation and what changed. Every part is written by the same workflow, which we built and run ourselves. These are its stages.
The question first.
Each dossier starts from two questions: what decides whether the business is worth more or less than people think, and what the market is loudly arguing about. Loud is not the same as true. Each loud claim that bears on the question is set against what the company has filed and comes back with a plain verdict, such as supported, partly supported, not supported by the filings, or open.
In the dossier Business explainer or What changed, under “What the market is debating”
Four researchers at once.
Four research agents work at the same time, each on one subject. One reads the numbers: the latest 10-Q or 10-K, its earnings release and the filings before them, up to eight quarters back. One reads management's record: what it guided to, what it promised, and a year of insider trades. One reads the business: its segments, customers, competition and risks, as the company describes them. One reads the earnings calls, up to eight of them, the latest two in full. Company figures come only from the company's SEC filings and its own releases.
At least the last eight guided quarters are scored beat, met or miss against management's own guidance, by a rule stated above the table, and each major promise is followed from the first time it was made to what became of it.
In the dossier Earnings, under “Management track record”; the Source line under every table; the sources list
Computed, not guessed.
Every growth rate, margin and valuation is computed in code from the reported figures, not estimated in the prose. The valuation sets out a bear, a base and a bull scenario, each with its drivers, a probability and a value per share, and is cross-checked with a second method. The share price is not an input to our scenarios: where a dossier states it, it comes at the end, as a comparison.
In the dossier Valuation and projections; figures labelled Moatsight est. or Scenario
Bear against bull.
A bear critic and a bull critic attack the draft. Each checks the figures that matter most to the conclusion against the filings and reruns the valuation with its own changes. A factual error either finds is fixed; other objections are accepted or rejected with a reason. The critics leave no notes in the text, so a dossier reads as one argument.
In the dossier No trace of the critics, by design
Checked before it is published.
A separate AI check with no web access, so it cannot browse or search, traces the company's reported figures to saved copies of the filings. It also flags a draft that follows instructions found on a web page, accuses anyone of wrongdoing without a primary source, or tells the reader what to buy or sell. A dossier the check flags is held back until Moatsight has read it.
In the dossier Nothing in the text: a dossier the check flags is not there to read until Moatsight has read it
§ 2
House rules
What the writer and the two critics are held to, in the draft and against it.
A dossier's view is Moatsight's, argued with its sources. Six rules in our workflow's instructions decide how it is formed.
Never invent a fact.
Every claim and every objection rests on numbers, filings or sound reasoning.
Concede where the other side is right.
A critique that only argues its own side changes nothing, so each critic says where the draft holds.
A factual error is always fixed.
A wrong number, period or attribution is corrected, whichever critic found it.
No splitting the difference.
An objection is accepted or rejected with a reason, never half-taken to please both critics.
The bear case is really bad. The bull case is really good.
The bear case is a realistic bad path for the business, not a recession in which profit still grows. When management has a long-term target, the bull case reaches it, or the dossier says why not.
The share price is not an input.
Scenario values come from the business. The price is stated, if at all, at the end, as a comparison.
No ratings, no personal advice, no ads. We show, you decide.
§ 3
What the check traces, and what it does not
The separate check runs last. This is its reach, stated plainly.
The check reads the finished dossier and saved copies of the documents it was written from. It has no web access, so it can only confirm what those copies hold. That decides what it can trace, and what a dossier marks another way.
Traced means the figure was found in a saved copy of a filing or release. It does not mean the dossier's reading of that figure is right.
| What a dossier states | The separate check | How the dossier marks it |
|---|---|---|
| Figures the company reported: revenue, profit, EPS, cash flow, segments, buybacks, and guidance published in a release or filing | Tracedto saved copies of the filings: at least every figure in the summary, the headline earnings table and the valuation inputs, then as many others as it can | The Source line under each table names the documents |
| Figures Moatsight worked out: growth rates, margins, per-share values | Sense-checkedfor plain inconsistency with the traced figures they come from; not traced | “Moatsight calculations” in the Source line; estimates labelled Moatsight est. or Scenario |
| What management said on a call or at another event | Not tracedno saved copy holds it | Quoted with the speaker, the event and the date |
| Outside facts: a market size, a share price, a news report | Not tracedthey come from outside the company | The outside source is named, in the text and in the sources list |
| Every table | Must name its sourcesa table without a Source line is held back | “Source: …” under the table |
Source: the separate check's instructions in Moatsight's workflow, as of Nov 7, 2026.
So a pass means the company's reported figures that the check looked for were found in its filings. It does not mean every sentence is right. The sources list of every dossier links the filings, so you can check what matters to you.
§ 4
Stopped in testing
One real case from our own testing, with the company and the figure left out.
Did not passOct 16, 2026 · in testing · an earlier version of our workflow
In our testing, a draft gave a quarter's data center costs as a figure from the filings. No filing contained it. The check stopped the draft, and it was never published.
- The statement
- A quarter's data center costs, given as a figure the company reported
- Found in
- No filing and no release
- What happened
- The draft was stopped. It was never published.
§ 5
Models, as of Oct 19, 2026
Dated, so this section says how current it is.
Dossiers are written and checked on current frontier AI models. The model for each agent is fixed in advance for every run, not picked on the day.
§ 6
Generated by AI
The notice every “AI-generated” label leads to.
Generated by AI
Moatsight's dossiers and summaries are written by an AI system from company filings, earnings materials and other sources listed with each dossier. While a dossier is written, AI critics argue against its draft, and before it is published a separate automated check traces the key figures the company reported to the sources. Dossiers flagged by our automated checks may be read and corrected by Moatsight before they are published. AI text can contain errors, omissions or outdated information. Check important facts against the primary sources before you rely on them.
No information about you is used to write a dossier. It is general research about a company, not advice for you: you decide.
About the method, answered plainly
What if a dossier gets something wrong?
Write to support@moatsight.com with “Correction:” and the company's ticker in the subject. Corrections are published as new versions of the edition, and an edition you unlocked stays readable with its corrections. A version that should not be read can be taken down, which withdraws its summary too.
Will it tell me what to do with a stock?
No. It is general research: what the filings say, how management's record holds up, and what the business could be worth under three stated scenarios. It gives no ratings and no personal advice. You decide.
Which AI models write the dossiers?
Current frontier AI models. The Models section above gives the date.
See the method at work in a whole dossier.
Browse free dossiers